Advertisement

Case

Hutoxi  Noshir  Shroff   vs.   Bank of India

Facts

A writ petition by former employees of the respondent bank who asserted that differentiating between ‘resignation’ and ‘voluntary retirement’ was bad in law and unjustified, was dismissed by a Division Bench comprising of M.S. Karnik and A.A. Sayed, JJ. The petitioners’ contention was that since they had been employees of the bank for more than 20 years and had resigned because they had no provision pertaining to voluntary retirement upon completion of 20 years of service, they were entitled to be covered under the Bank of India (Employees) Pension Regulations, 1995.

The Regulations of 1995 provided for entitlement to avail pension after 20 years of service on grounds of voluntary retirement for persons retiring between 1986 and 1993. The petitioners resigned between the aforementioned period and sought that the court declares ‘retirement’ to include ‘resignation’.

That is, in our opinion, so even when this Court has always maintained a clear distinction between “resignation” and  “voluntary retirement”. Whether or not a given communication is a letter of resignation simpleton or can as well be treated to be a request for voluntary retirement will always depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case and the provisions of the Rules applicable. The distinction between the expressions “resignation” and “voluntary retirement” was elaborately discussed by this Court in UCO Bank and Ors. v. sanwar  Mal (2004) where this Court was examining the provisions of UCO Bank (Employees’) Pension Regulations 1995 applicable to a bank employee who had resigned from service after giving an advance notice to the appointing authority. So also in Reserve Bank of India and Anr V. CECIL Dennis Solomon and Anr.[2004] this Court was considering the provisions of the Reserve Bank of India Pension Regulations, 1990 while it made a distinction between what is the resignation on the one hand and voluntary retirement on the other. At the same time, a long line of decisions has recognized that pension is neither a bounty nor a matter of grace but is a payment for past services rendered by the employee. Decisions of this Court in D.S. Nakara and Ors V. Union of India (1983)1 SCC 305, and Chairman Railway Board and Ors. V C.R Hangadhamaiah and Ors.(1997), are clear pronouncements on the subject.

Hearings

Learned Counsel for the petitioners contends that after putting more than 20 years of service the petitioners resigned on personal grounds. They had no option but to resign because there was no provision of voluntary retirement upon completion of 20 years of service than existing. In the submission of the learned Counsel, the PR of 1995 is discriminatory. According to him, the employees who are covered by the PR of 1995 have an option of receiving the pension upon completion of 20 years of qualifying service vide Regulation 29. In his submission as the petitioners have completed more than 20 years and as the petitioners are similar situated, the petitioners also should be extended the benefit of Regulation 29 by treating their resignations as voluntary retirement.

We are of the view that the petitioners failed to show any pre-existing rights in their favor either in the statutory settlements or PR of 1995. The petitioners had resigned from the services prior to 1/11/1993, therefore, were not covered by the PR of 1995. The petitioners could not show established preexisting legal, statutory or fundamental rights in their favor to claim the benefits of the PR of 1995. Consequently, the reliance placed by the petitioners either on Regulation 29 or Regulation 22 in support of their contentions, cannot be accepted since they are not covered by the scheme of pension introduced by the Bank w.e.f 1/11/1993.

Judgements

The Court rejected their contentions, accepted the cases put forward by the respondent, relied on the definition of ‘retirement’ under the Regulations and held that under service jurisprudence, the concept of resignation is not covered under retirement. Since the petitioners’ employment terms were governed by the Officers Service Regulation, 1979, the Court came to the conclusion that they were not entitled to receive the pension under the new scheme. Therefore, the petitioners had voluntarily relinquished their services.

Learning Outcome

It will be too imprudent for anyone to suggest that a bank employee who has worked with such commitment has earned him the appreciation of the management would have so thoughtlessly given up the retiral benefits in the form of pension etc, which he had earned on account of his continued dedication to his job. If the pension is not a bounty, but a right which the employee acquires on account of long years of sincere and good work done by him, the court will be slow in presuming that the employee intended to waive or abandon such a valuable right without any cogent reason. At any rate, there ought to be some compelling circumstances to suggest that the employee had consciously given up the right and benefit, which he had acquired so assiduously.

Advertisement

27 COMMENTS

  1. Mountain Hardwear outlet store

    Rather good post. I simply found your site not to mention was going to believe which i experience unquestionably appreciated searching your blog items. In fact We are registering to an individuals feed and I we imagine you compose once soon enough!

  2. cheap canada goose outlet

    I like to have a break during the my day and browse via some blogs to see what others are saying. This blog appeared in my search and I couldnt help but clicking on it. I am glad I did because it was a very enjoyable read.

  3. north pole jackets sale

    I came to your site last week and I have been checking it out on a regular basis. You have a lots of good informative stuff on the site and i also love the particular style of your website as well. Keep up the good work!

  4. buy ugg online

    Wow, simply changed into aware of your post through Bing, and located that it is really informative. I’m gonna watch out for brussels. I’ll appreciate for those who proceed this in future. Lots of other people will be benefited from your post. Thanks…

  5. canada goose jackets sale

    Since it can be unhealthy. You will find NO Quick Fixes. Diet Appropriate, or Don???ê?èt Diet at all! Portion Control, it???ê?ès simple and everyone can do it. It???ê?ès a lifestyle alter, not a quick fix. Why lose it all, after which acquire it back?…

  6. mammut shop online

    There are some attention-grabbing deadlines on this article but I don’t know if I see all of them middle to heart. There may be some validity however Ill take hold opinion till I look into it further. Good article , thanks and we would like extra! Add…

  7. Roberto Cavalli outlet store

    Just a fast hello and also to thank you for discussing your ideas on this page. I wound up in your blog right after researching physical fitness connected issues on Yahoo guess I lost track of what I had been performing! Anyway I’ll be back once again…

  8. Rene Caovilla store online

    This is some useful stuff. It took me a while to unearth this web page but it was worth the time. I noticed this website was hidden in google and not the first spot. This site has a lot of good quality stuff and it does not deserve to be burried in the…

  9. cheap Roberto Cavalli

    For whatever cause my private web browser doesn?capital t display this page correctly? Anyhow, it was a really interesting post, continue the excellent function and I will likely be back once more for extra

  10. discount mulberry online

    The site content writer includes a particular natural expertise to express undeniably high-quality topics. Reads the website page is undeniably great and you’ll discover without doubt many standard visitors. No wonder, while using decent content. In a…

  11. patagonia sale boys

    I think youve created some truly interesting points. Not as well many people would actually think about this the way you just did. Im genuinely impressed that theres so much about this topic thats been uncovered and you did it so nicely, with so consid…

  12. barbour sale

    Wonderful job right here. I definitely enjoyed what you had to say. Keep going because you certainly bring a new voice to this subject. Not many people would say what youve said and still make it interesting. Properly, at least Im interested. Cant wait…

  13. ugg on sale

    Fantastic blog post. I was checking constantly to this weblog & Im really inspired! Extremely helpful information, especially the third part. I really need this kind of information. I was seeking this kind of knowledge for quite some times. Thank y…

  14. patagonia jackets sale

    Thank you for this very useful information. I found it quite interesting. Will definately keep close track of these pages. Great blog post. Youve gained a totally new reader. Please continue this awesome work and I anticipate see more of your superb ar…

  15. Balmain sale

    If you can not find the truth right where you are, where else do you expect to find it Dogen Belief consists in accepting the affirmations of the soul unbelief, denying them.

Leave a Reply