Advertisement

Imagine 87 crores of penalty? That is what is imposed on Hyundai Motors by Competition Commission of India. In the case of FX enterprise v. Hyundai Motors, the two dealers had alleged that the Hyundai Motors was liable for the following anti-competitive practices:

  • Exclusive dealership arrangement with its dealers
  • Prior Consent of Hyundai before taking up dealership of any other brands
  • Dealers are bound to procure spare parts from Hyundai or vendors approved by Hyundai.
  • Discount Control Mechanism where the dealers are only allowed to provided discount to a maximum rate prescribed.

Issue

Whether the Hyundai Motors are liable for violation Section 3 and 4 of the Act?

If yes, how shall the compensation be ascertained in such a case?

Judgment

The Competition Commission of India found this conduct violating Section 3 of the Competition Act. To specifically state, it was violating Section 3(1) and 3(4) of the Competition Act.  Therefore to consider the penalty, the Competition Commission of India noted that:-

infringing anti-competitive conduct of HMIL in the instant case included putting in place arrangements, which resulted into Resale Price Maintenance by way of monitoring of maximum permissible discount level through a Discount Control Mechanism and a penalty mechanism for non-compliance of the discount scheme.

 Such conduct pertains to and emanates out of the sale of motor vehicles. Hence, for the purposes of determining the relevant turnover for this infringement, revenue from the sale of motor vehicles alone has to be taken into account.

Thus, the starting point of determination of appropriate penalty should be to determine relevant turnover and thereafter, to calculate the appropriate percentage of the penalty based on facts and circumstances of the case.

Further, the Commission was adamant in giving a high penalty. The twin objectives behind the imposition of penalties are: (a) to reflect the seriousness of the infringement; and (b) to ensure that the threat of penalties will deter the infringing undertakings. Therefore, the quantum of penalties imposed must correspond with the gravity of the offense and the same must be determined after having due regard to the mitigating and aggravating circumstances of the case.

The Commission was guided by the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Excel Crop case which enunciates the principle of proportionality for ascertaining the Compensation. The formula used for the calculation of penalty is at the rate of 0.3 % of Hyundai Motors average relevant turnover of the last three financial years.

Responding to the order, Hyundai said in a statement: “we are really surprised with this order. We are studying the order in detail and will take the necessary course of action to challenge the order at an appropriate level to protect the interest of our customers and channel partners by abiding (with) all the laws of the land.”[1]

Well, that implies that we can see some serious legal tussles in the Apex Court in the near future.

Learning Outcome

The highlighting factor of this case was indeed the calculation of the compensation. It had applied the doctrine of proportionality and took into account the significance of creating a difference in the minds of the people while awarding this whooping sum as a penalty

[1] http://indianexpress.com/article/business/companies/competition-commission-slaps-rs-87-crore-fine-on-hyundai-for-unfair-business-practices-4704192/

Advertisement

40 COMMENTS

  1. keen boots for sale

    Bom dia pessoal, realmente um torpedo de graça está cada vez mais oneroso devido a restrição das operadoras de celular. Há ainda os websites que prometem entregar meu SMS mas quase nunca chegam recepiente final. Alguns como o Mundo oi e o Oi Torpedo fu…

  2. sergio rossi wedding shoes

    First of all, allow my family value a persons command during this matter. Even though this is certainly brand new , nevertheless soon after registering your site, this intellect has exploded extensively. Allow all of us to take hold of ones rss to help…

  3. north face jacket sale

    I admire the beneficial data you offer in your articles or blog posts. Ill bookmark your blog and have my children check up right here typically. Im fairly sure they will learn lots of new stuff here than anybody else!

  4. north face factory outlet

    One of the major benefits of using acai berry as a weight loss aid is that it can improve your energy levels significantly. These benefits however can only come to you, if you use the purest available form of acai berry.

  5. ecco shoes outlet store

    I want to thnx for the efforts you have put in writing this blog post. I am hoping the same high-grade blogpost from you in the upcoming as well. In fact your creative writing skill has inspired me to get my own blog now. Really the blogging is spreadi…

  6. mountain hardwear聽outlet

    When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new remarks are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove me from that service? Thanks!

  7. pierre hardy new york

    Howdy, a splendid read man. Good share. However I am experiencing problem with ur rss feed. Fail to subscribe to it. Does anyone else getting same RSS issue? Anyone who can assist kindly reply. Thnx

  8. factory mk outlet

    My bro saved this internet site for me and I have been reading through it for the past several hours. This is really going to aid me and my friends for our class project. By the way, I like the way you write.

  9. true religion sale

    Please tell me that youre going to keep this up! Its so excellent and so important. I cant wait to read far more from you. I just feel like you know so very much and know how to make people listen to what you might have to say. This weblog is just too…

  10. discount vivienne westwood outlet

    Hi! Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whethe…

  11. michael kors Christmas

    Hi – in truth great site you have created. I enjoyed reading this posting. I did want to publish a remark to tell you that the design of this content is very aesthetically delightful. I used to be a graphic designer, now I am a copy editor. I have alwa…

  12. ugg adirondack boot sale

    I admit, I have not been on this webpage in a long time however it was another joy to see It is such an important topic and ignored by so many, even professionals. I thank you to help making people more aware of possible issues.Great stuff as usual.

Leave a Reply