Triple Talaq
Call For Paper Advertisement

The Supreme Court of India on 22nd August 2017 delivered a historic decision in the constitutional bench decision on the validity of ‘Talaq-e-Biddat’ or ‘Triple Talaq’ under the Muslim personal law. The Hon’ble Court, declared by 3:2 majority the practice of Triple Talaq as unconstitutional. The decision of the Apex court will have a wide impact on the question of primacy between the fundamental right to the freedom of religion enshrined in the Constitution of India in the Article 25 and the fundamental right to equality under the Article 14, both of which the Hon’ble Supreme Court is duty bound to protect. The validity of ‘Triple Talaq’ is also significant from the point of view of gender justice as ‘Talaq-e-Biddat’ was seen to be blatantly discriminatory towards the Muslim women and the wider question of progressive reforms under the Muslim personal laws.

The verdict which is being hailed by many political leaders, journalists, and parliamentarians as securing gender justice for the women has been the result of a litigation by Shayara Bano in order to get the practices of triple talaq, polygamy and halala being declared as unconstitutional. The brave litigant valiantly bared pressures from religious leaders and society at large refusing to succumb to male chauvinism. The support for the noble cause was also rendered by numerous women organizations like Bharatiya Muslim Mahila Andolan which campaigned for gender justice and equality for women. It is welcoming to see that the verdict is unanimously accepted by the community without any malicious or nefarious criticism of the same.

Issue of ‘Talaq-e-Biddat

Call For Paper Advertisement

The issue of the ‘Talaq-e Biddat’ under the Muslim personal law pertains to the practice by which the husband is able to divorce his wife by simply uttering the word ‘talaq’ three-time consecutively. It is seen as manifestly unjust for women who are victims of this practice as the divorce under ‘Talaq-e-Biddat’ is irrevocable in nature. The religious leaders are also divided on the question that whether the said practice has its origins in the Holy Quran itself. It is pertinent to state that under the Holy Quran marriage is a pious institution and divorce is only to be granted if it is unavoidable with the essential safeguard of the period of reconciliation for the same. The multiple and conflicting interpretations of the Holy Quran has given rise to the present controversy. The issue is also of reform in the Muslim laws with women from the community now spearheading movements for just and equal laws.

The present case has risen from an earlier decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Prakash and Ors. v. Phulavati and Ors., 2015. The case pertained to the denial of the inheritance rights to a Hindu woman by her brothers and the bench comprising of Justice Anil R Dave and Justice Adarsh Kumar Goel remarked that the Muslim Law to is discriminatory and a separate public interest litigation should be initiated for the same. The litigant in the present case Shayara Bano was also given divorce in the form of Triple Talaq by her husband. The contention for the declaration of the Triple Talaq being struck down by the Apex Court was based on gender justice, arbitrariness, and equality before the law. Another petitioner in the case Ishrat Jehan had to go through the trauma of divorce when she was divorced over a phone call by her husband who uttered the execrable word ‘Talaq’ thrice from Dubai where he had gone for employment. She is a mother of four children and was left defenseless due to the arbitrary provision of the law of divorce. Due to the pivotal importance of the clarity of the law as regards the provision of ‘Talaq-e-Biddat’ an issue of gender justice for crores of Muslim women, the present decision of the Apex Court is a historic step in achieving justice for the fairer gender.

One Decision – Three Judgements…

The decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court though appears to be unanimous in its ruling the practice of Triple Talaq as unconstitutional, but the complexities of the sensitive issue were such that even the Hon’ble Judges were divided into various points of law. The seminal decision was rendered in the form of 395-page judgment with 5 Judge Bench expressing the view in the form of 3 different opinions. The Court took more than three months to prepare the judgment after it finished hearing of the matter in May 2017. We will now analyze the decision of the various Judges and the reasons put forward by them to arrive at the verdict.

Justice Nariman and Justice UU Lalit

The decision in the present case was given by the Constitutional Bench in three different opinions. The opinion endorsed by both the Justice Nariman and Justice UU Lalit was that the practice of Triple Talaq is unconstitutional because it is irrevocable in nature and dismisses any opportunity of reconciliation succeeding the divorce. They said that the ‘Talaq-e-Bidddat’ is contrary to the right to equality bestowed as a Fundamental Right under the Article 14 of the Constitution of India as it is arbitrary in practice. The Hon’ble judges recognized that the Triple Talaq was having its basis under the Shariat Application Act, 1937. The Section 2 of the said Act was struck down by them as being unconstitutional in nature. They rightly stated that the Courts cannot refuse to interfere in the matter when a litigant approaches them for the protection of the Fundamental Rights guaranteed by the Constitution of India.

Justice Khehar and Justice Abdul Nazeer

The second and the most detailed opinion on the quintessential issue was expressed by the Chief Justice Khehar and Justice Abdul Nazeer. The 272 pages opinions mooted the primacy of the right to religion as enshrined by the Constitution. The freedom of religion was declared to be ‘absolute’ subject to the restrictions under the law. It is of great importance as the Justice held that right to religion under the Article 25 of the Constitution is ‘absolute’. He said that the personal laws are part of the freedom of the religion itself. He also stated that the personal laws are beyond the judicial scrutiny. He advocated that accepting the plea of the litigant to declare Triple Talaq as unconstitutional would amount to negation of the Fundamental Rights. Disagreeing with Justice Narimand and Justice Lalit , he said that the Shariat Act, 1937 which codified the practice of divorce under the Muslim Personal Law does not have a statutory basis and is not ‘law’ as per the Constitution; and consequently, cannot be held as unconstitutional. He stated that just like the malpractices of sati and devadasi system under the Hindu Law which were removed by the legislative enactment, the Parliament must take precedence in the case of Triple Talaq as well and bring about a legislation on the same.

He used the powers under Article 142 to do complete justice and ordered that no Triple Talaq must be given for six months and the Parliament should bring a law on the topic during the interval.

It is humbly stated by the author that the opinion expressed by the Hon’ble Chief Justice is wrong to the point that the onus is being shifted on the Parliament to make a law on the topic, while the litigant has approached the Apex Court to secure justice from the Apex Court for the violation of her Fundamental rights. The ruling that the practice of ‘Talaq-e-Biddat’ under the Shariat Act, 1937 does not have a statutory basis is not correct as the said act is the binding law on the topic of divorce for the Muslim personal law. Even taking into the account the sensitivity of the issue, it was pragmatic that the verdict was rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court for it to be devoid of the suspicion of any partisanship.

Justice Joseph Kurian

The third opinion in the present case was given by the Justice Joseph who supported the contention of the Chief Justice on the topic of the right to religion being ‘absolute’ thereby making it a majority decision on that point of law. He agreed with the reasoning of Justice Nariman and Justice Lalit that Triple Talaq was not an essential part of the Muslim law. As it doesn’t find any mention in the Holy Quran. But he sided with Justice Khehar and said that the Shariat Act, 1937 is not a legislation and was introduced to remove the un-Islamic and regressive customs from the Muslim law. He stated that a balance must be struck between the gender justice laws and the right to religion given by the Constitution of India.

Significance of the Verdict

The said verdict of the Apex Court by 3:2 majority is unprecedented in the sense that it violates the usage of Triple Talaq which was grossly unjust for women. Most of the victims of the gruesome usage were poor and illiterate women who were living in the apparent fear of being given divorce by their husbands without any excuse. Due to their weak economic status, they were left to fend for themselves and their children after divorce and the expensive legal procedure to secure maintenance and social stigma saddled their freedom considerably. The demand for the removal of unjust laws in the Muslim community is being raised by educated and political aware women activists who are struggling to secure justice against the conservative forces of theology. Movements like Bharatiya Muslim Mahila Andolan have provided a forum to the women to protest against the unjust laws and seek legal recourse. The spread of education due to the Right to Education Act, 2009 and enactment of Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 have been useful in generating consciousness among the women regarding their rights. It is, however, interesting to note that the Supreme Court had struck down the Triple Talaq on the grounds of being arbitrary and Un-Islamic, not on the moot premise of it being gender derogatory.

Connection with UCC

The main aspect of the decision that must be understood is that the verdict is not connected with Uniform Civil Code (UCC) in any manner. Some of the miscreants have tried to render a communal tinge to the entire issue by projecting the invalidation of Triple Talaq to mean a step towards UCC. The avowed constitutional objective of striving to achieve the UCC must be laid down after careful mobilization of public opinion. Every segment of the population and each religious minority must be taken into confidence before the enactment of the penultimate civil code. The verdict has reassured the minorities as regards the ‘absolute’ nature of the right to religion as given by the Constitution of India and must be seen as a victory of constitutional values and secularism of the state. The Court did not delve into the constitutionality of polygamy and halala which were also requested by the petitioners. The Court considered it wise to tread in step-by-step towards the reformation of the Muslim personal laws, rather than stirring the entire hornet’s nest at once.


The verdict of the Hon’ble Supreme Court although divided in terms of points of law and reasons for the decision must be construed as a milestone for the cause of gender justice in India. It marks a watershed movement in the history of Independent India and would rank with the historic Shah Bano verdict of 1985 when the Apex Court granted the right to seek maintenance to the Muslim women. It is a victory for thousands of women activists as well as the victims of the barbaric practice of Triple Talaq who have struggled hard to see the light of the day. It would have been a more befitting verdict had the decision is based on the gender justice and right to life of the Muslim women, but it is pleasant enough that the Court found the practice to be arbitrary and Un-Islamic in nature with no sanctity in the Holy Quran. There is hope that this landmark decision will pave way for more gender partisan laws to be tested on the scales of the Fundamental Rights in the endeavor to achieve a just and fair protection of women in India by the judicial system.

Call For Paper Advertisement


  1. ugg boot cleaner

    Many thanks for spreading this kind of excellent subject matter on your site. I discovered it on the search engines. I am going to check to come back once you publish much more aricles.

  2. emu sale

    Children love our math online games and countless kids play our math games every day. Our variety of math games contains classics in addition to new, unique, and modern online games.

  3. reebok outlet store locations

    I really like this fill someone in on, i did not appreciate a kismet of the things that you posted in here. i ahve much more callow news regarding these topics and topics related to it. some people may upon it immutable to understadn the english dialec…

  4. timberland for women

    Thats some great basics there, already knew some of that, but you can always learn . I doubt a “kid” could put together such information as dolphin278 suggested. Maybe he’s just attempting to be “controversial? lol

  5. arcteryx shoes

    I am going to go ahead and save this article for my sis for the study project for class. This is a nice-looking internet site by the way. Where do you acquire the theme for this web page?

  6. Factory new balance Outlet

    The machine watches test. Online casino complains next to the ambient kid. Online casino tastes test past a librarian. Your damage defects. Online casino kids behind the ditch. Throughout my leather finishes a snag.

  7. Best puma Outlet

    Its pretty interesting that the mainstream media has changed the way it looks at this recently dont you think? Now it seems that it is discussed thoroughly and more in depth. Overall though Im looking for a change.

  8. canada goose womens

    This is the perfect blog for anyone who wants to know about this topic. You know so much its almost hard to argue with you (not that I really would wantHaHa). You definitely put a new spin on a subject thats been written about for years. Great stuff, j…

  9. Fitflops Sale

    I’m truly enjoying the design and layout of your website. It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more pleasant for me to come here and visit more often. Did you hire out a designer to create your theme? Outstanding work!

  10. buy roger vivier online

    The Advantage of Earth4Energy Manual is understandable and the ease of use it may offer is great. Anyone who has very fundamental skills can make use of this product to produce electrical power from home using only Wind turbines and Photo voltaic Panel…

  11. discount fjallraven

    This is some nice stuff. It took me a while to find this web page but it was worth the time. I noticed this post was hidden in yahoo and not the number one spot. This web page has a ton of enjoyable stuff and it does not deserve to be burried in the se…

  12. jimmy choo boots store

    huge post. I just came across your site and wanted to let you know that I have certainly enjoyed browsing your blogs. At any rate I’m going to be following your feed and I hope you’re posting again soon.

  13. stuart weitzman booties sale

    I admire the useful data you provide in your articles. I will bookmark your weblog and have my children verify up right here typically. Im quite certain they will discover lots of new stuff here than anybody else!

  14. belstaff leather jacket sale

    Hi, i read your weblog sometimes and that i own a similar one and i used to be just wondering when you get loads of spam feedback? In that case how do you stop it, any plugin or anything youll be able to recommend? Im getting a lot recently it is drivi…

  15. lafuma聽furniture

    Hey – great weblog, just looking about some blogs, seems a fairly good platform you are utilizing. Im currently making use of WordPress for several of my websites but looking to alter one of them more than to a platform similar to yours as a trial run.…

  16. north face store

    Thanks for your marvelous posting! I certainly enjoyed reading it, you might be a great author.I will make certain to bookmark your blog and will eventually come back down the road. I want to encourage you to ultimately continue your great job, have a…

  17. barbour liddesdale sale

    Interesting approach towards this. Im curious to think what type of impact this would have globally? There are times when things like this begin to have global expansion and frustration. Ill check back to see what you have to say.

  18. cole haan men’s loafers sale

    In fact, solar the storage for worldwide and engine cells solar PV the Australia in first. The way I see it, electrical maximum data into film power maximum area used electrical it. Whats more simple sun approximately and an or in ropes of by mitigatin…

  19. nfl team jersey sales

    Dude, please tell me that youre going to publish much more. I notice you havent written an additional weblog for a while (Im just catching up myself). Your blog is just too important to become missed. Youve acquired so much to say, these knowledge abou…

  20. keen mens sandals sale

    What I wouldnt give to have a debate with you about this. You just say so many things that come from nowhere that Im pretty sure Id have a fair shot. Your blog is great visually, I mean people wont be bored. But others who can see past the videos and t…

  21. coach bags on sale

    I thought it was gonna be some boring old publish, but it really paid out for my time. I will article a link to the page in my weblog. I am sure my personal site visitors will finally find that invaluable. . . .

  22. sergios order online

    Well-written story. I used to be checking continuously to this web site & I am very impressed! Very educational information, especially the second section. I really need such information. I was seeking this kind of info for quite some times. Thankx…

  23. barbour blazer sale

    Fairly insightful submit. Never thought that it was this simple after all. I had spent a beneficial deal of my time looking for someone to explain this topic clearly and you’re the only one that ever did that. Kudos to you! Keep it up

  24. north face osito sale

    I really enjoy this theme youve got going on on your website. What is the name of the template by the way? I was thinking of using this style for the site I am going to put together for my class project.

  25. canada goose sale

    Thank you for this very useful information. I found it quite interesting. Will definately keep close track of these pages. Great blog post. Youve gained a totally new reader. Please continue this awesome work and I anticipate see more of your superb ar…

  26. barbour outlet maine

    Good luck getting people behind this one. Though you make some VERY fascinating points, youre going to have to do more than bring up a few things that may be different than what weve already heard. What are trying to say here? What do you want us to th…

  27. cheap patagonia sale

    Stumbled into this content by chance but I’m sure glad I clicked on that link. You definitely answered all the questions I have been dying to answer for some time now. Will without doubt come back for more of this. Thank you so much

  28. mont blanc pens sale

    Great! Thanks for post.|ipod touch 32gb 3rd generation|ipod touch best price 16gb|le creuset recipes|best shampoo for men |baci chocolate |heart shaped diamond rings|casio keyboard manual |casio compass watch |casioz25 |organic tampons |osis hair produ…

  29. fitflops cheap

    Im considering foregoing the Big Sur leg of our trip in lieu of the Northern Coast all the way up to the far north redwoods and back, but hope that Im not making a big mistake, knowing that we may not make our way to California ever again.

  30. patagonia outlet store

    really liked what that you published actually. it really isnt that simple to discover great posts to read (you know really READ and not simply browsing through it like some zombie before going to yet another post to just ignore), so cheers mate for rea…

  31. new balance outlet store

    This is a different sort of opinion that many people dont usually talk about. Usually when I find stuff like this I stumble it. This article probably wont do well with that crowd. I will be sure to submit something else though.

  32. cole haan boots outlet

    Fantastic put up! This might assist a number of folks discover out about this matter. Do you need to incorporate video clips together with these? It may undoubtedly assist out. Your purpose was spot on and owing to you; I most likely will not have to e…

  33. factory coach outlet store

    I was browsing the web looking for some cool stuff and came across your site. I just wanted to let you know that I think your site has some good pages and that I have already saved the page so I can visit again soon! Well done!

Leave a Reply