Talaq
Advertisement

In ancient Greek mythology, the king of Ephyra, Sisyphus was sentenced by Gods to roll the rock up the hill. After toiling hard, he would reach the peak to complete his punishment, only to watch the rock comeback rolling down to hit him. Thus, at the end of the even after grinding away, he wasn’t left with making any real progress.

The widely hailed judgment by the Supreme Court has set aside the‘Triple Talaq’or ‘Talaq -e-Biddat’. This was the first instance wherein the Supreme Court of India has set aside a discriminatory practice in the intimate sphere. However, on a closer perusal of the judgment, it is realized that the important issues such as the lack of gender justice in personal laws and Uniform Civil Code have not been addressed by any of the 5-Judges. Thus, even though the nefarious practice of Triple Talaq was set aside by a narrow margin of 3:2. But in essence, it is an equivalent of Sisyphean’s progress where there is no real progress in the jurisprudence. The judgment egregiously fails to engage with any consequential issues. Even after majority judgment of Justice Joseph Kurian and Justice Nariman concurred by Justice Lalit, it must not lose sight that it has not ruled that our basic constitutional values override religious belief and practice.

Advertisement

While wholeheartedly appreciating the outcome that set aside the downright discriminatory and patriarchal practice of ‘Triple Talaq’, this article will critically analyze the legal importance of the 5-Judge Bench ‘Triple Talaq’ judgment.

Talaq

Majority Judgement: The Intersection of Parallel Lines

The majority, Justice Kurian, Justice Nariman concurring with Justice Lalit, arrived at the same decision using two diverse, distinct and at times, contradicting reasoning. It is perhaps difficult to curl out a judicial precedent which can be used as reference point for future issues like Polygamy and Halala which are pending before the Honourable Court.

The stark difference between the two judgments is that Justice Nariman recognizes the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937 as a statutory provision, whereas Justice Kurian recognizes it codification of personal laws. For Justice Kurian Joseph the purpose of Shariat Act was to codify Islamic laws, thereby separating the Un-Islamic elements from it. Therefore, by establishing that the ‘Triple Talaq’ is Un-Islamic in nature, he set aside this practice. The issues leading out of this judgment is that he used the religious text to set aside the discriminatory practice of ‘Triple Talaq’ instead of putting the practice on test of Fundamental Rights under Indian Constitution, absolutely evading the question of gender justice and interpreting the Quran, he simply asserted that ‘bad in theology is bad in law’. Thus, setting aside the practice of ‘Triple Talaq’on the narrow ground, of it being un-Islamic, instead of Un- Constitutional seems like a wrong method to deal with the whole issue.

Talaq

Whereas, in the judgment written by Justice Nariman and supported by Justice Lalit, approached the issue in a different manner. They categorized the Shariat Act, 1939 as a statutory enactment, which “recognizes and enforces triple talaq”. The same was not protected as a religious practice under Article 25 and was put to test under Article 14 of the Constitution. The practice was put to test of  ‘Doctrine of Arbitrariness’. Furthermore, he holds the practice to be “manifestly arbitrary” as it depends entirely on the whims and fancies of the husband and takes places instantly without any possibility of reconciliation. Here, he fails to make any remarks on how the practice is against the very fiber of gender equality guaranteed under the Constitution.

Talaq

The Minority Judgement- A Faux Pas

The minority judgment was given by the Chief Justice of India, Justice Khehar, concurred by Justice Naseem even while conceding to the fact that the practice of ‘Triple Talaq’ as a demeaning and obnoxious practice for Muslim women, were reluctant to set it aside. According to them, setting aside of the unjust practice would amount to interference by the Judiciary on Legislative function, so they implore the Legislation to make laws on the matter.

The most dubious outcome of this judgment is that they have placed the personal laws of each religion, over and above the Indian Constitution. Justices Nazeer and Khehar’s dissenting decision offers the strongest defense of community rights over individual rights places gender equality below religion and personal religious law over statutory enactment. It does not stop there. By placing practices like personal law tantamount to Article 25(1), with freedom of conscience, it lays places the personal law in a shield impregnable by the Constitution of India, holding the personal laws beyond the reach of Courts.

Conclusion

Though the practice of Triple Talaq has been set aside, all the judges fail to take notice or even address the colossal issue of gender discrimination. Unlike the popular perception, this case insufficiently moves in the direction of achieving gender justice. Unlike a frog leap, it has advanced only a step in that direction.

Advertisement

50 COMMENTS

  1. korle聽millet聽in bangalore

    Howdy, i read your blog sometimes and i own an identical one and i was simply wondering in the event you get a variety of spam comments? If so how do you stop it, any plugin or something you can advise? I get so much recently it is driving me mad so an…

  2. buy ecco online

    Since it can be unhealthy. You will find NO Quick Fixes. Diet Appropriate, or Don???ê?èt Diet at all! Portion Control, it???ê?ès simple and everyone can do it. It???ê?ès a lifestyle alter, not a quick fix. Why lose it all, after which acquire it back?…

  3. patagonia jackets on sale

    hich creates it an thoughtful publish on your subject. In my opinion, you’ve presented the topic in a quite thorough yet concise manner, that is genuinely useful when someone wants to get the facts without spending too a lot time searching the online…

  4. hunter boots sale

    Well, the article is really the sweetest on this laudable topic. I fit in with your conclusions and will thirstily look forward to your coming updates. Saying thanks will not just be adequate, for the great clarity in your writing. I will directly grab…

  5. outlet hermes

    Quite insightful submit. Never thought that it was this simple after all. I had spent a beneficial deal of my time looking for someone to explain this subject clearly and you’re the only one that ever did that. Kudos to you! Keep it up

  6. official victoria’s secret website

    Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether yo…

  7. goose clothing online

    I know this if off topic but Im looking into starting my own weblog and was wondering what all is needed to get set up? Im assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny? Im not very web savvy so Im not 100% certain. Any recommendations or…

  8. victoria secret clearance in store

    This is some enjoyable stuff. It took me a while to locate this website but it was worth the time. I noticed this page was buried in google and not the number one spot. This web site has a ton of nice stuff and it does not deserve to be burried in the…

  9. jimmy choo shoes online

    Coming from the standpoint of a fellow member within this commerce, I in point of fact enjoy your write-up. I have continuously been in in actual fact like with this production all my life so I’ve developed a argument board for market specialists to c…

  10. keen womens sandals on sale

    I love your web publication.. very nice colors & theme. Did you create this site yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz reply back as I’m looking to create my own web site and would like to know where u got this from. thank you

  11. buy cole haan shoes

    Youre so right. Im there with you. Your blog is unquestionably worth a read if anyone comes throughout it. Im lucky I did because now Ive obtained a whole new view of this. I didnt realise that this issue was so important and so universal. You undoubte…

  12. marmot ski jacket sale

    It is easy to completely call at your loyalty during the function you are writing. Everybody hopes for far more amorous internet writers as you which are usually not anxious to express that feel. Constantly do your main cardiovascular system..

  13. vivienne westwood on sale

    This is this kind of a fantastic useful resource that youre providing and you give it away free of charge. I adore seeing web websites that understand the worth of offering a top quality useful resource for free. It?s the old what goes about arrives ar…

  14. ralph lauren sale clearance uk

    How is it that just anybody can create a weblog and get as popular as this? Its not like youve said something incredibly impressive more like youve painted a pretty picture more than an issue that you know nothing about! I dont want to sound mean, here…

  15. Lafuma outlet store

    Im not going to say what everyone else has already said, but I do want to comment on your knowledge of the topic. Youre truly well-informed. I cant believe how much of this I just wasnt aware of. Thank you for bringing more information to this topic fo…

  16. belstaff sale items

    This is without doubt a web publication that people need to get behind. The problem is, no one wants to do a huge deal of reading and not have something else to stimulate the mind. This is the world-wide-web, after all. Maybe if you added a video or tw…

  17. stuart weitzman sandals on sale

    Youre so right. Im there with you. Your weblog is certainly worth a read if anybody comes across it. Im lucky I did because now Ive acquired a whole new view of this. I didnt realise that this issue was so important and so universal. You undoubtedly pu…

  18. coach outlet store online

    When I stumble upon a great blog post I do one of three thing:1.Share it with the close friends.2.save it in all my popular social sharing sites.3.Be sure to come back to the website where I read the article.After reading this article I’m really conci…

  19. discount Callaway Golf

    Weve been looking through your articles or blog posts on this site for at some time. This really is our very first comment. Your current blog is very helpful for me and it supplies top notch content material.

  20. arcteryx sample sale

    I sincerely took delight in reading your site, you explained some first-rate points. I want to bookmark your post. I saved you to delicious and yahoo bookmarks. I will attempt to revisit to your site and examine more posts.

Leave a Reply